Wednesday, February 10, 2010

My Name is ......

The current tussle between the Sena and SRK has added another low to the regional politics of Mumbai. I have always felt very strongly about the importance of regional politics in general and its ability to represent the aspirations of the local populations in particular. I am a liberal and I am not against migration in principal, but I also am aware of the socio-economic impacts of this phenomenon and its ability to alter the cultural and social fabric of a community along with the constant strain on the dwindling infrastructure. In that regard some of my ideas would closely resonate with the objectives of political parties like the Sena or the MNS but I guess it ends at that. The means and methods adopted by the practitioners of this ideology only send shivers down my spine, simply because I would not like to be at the receiving end of the treatment that is meted out or probably because, I am only a third generation Mumbaikar.

But as I sat down to pen my thoughts about the recent turn of events I received an email which contained an open letter to SRK by Mr. Bandyopadhyay Arindam which did touch upon many of the aspects that I had in my mind. I shall build upon some of the points made therein and present my viewpoint on engaging with Pakistan.

First about the comments made by SRK, I must say, that although I respect his right to express his views and beliefs, I do not agree with most of the things that he said. I have a very clear position on what kind of relations we must have with Pakistan. I think that we must not engage with our neighbours in any way until and unless the government across the border is able to perform substantially and credibly on dismantling the existing terror frameworks in Pakistan. As much as I believe that peace is the only way forward and cultivating hatred will only lead to more hatred, I would not want art, culture, sport, cinema, and laughter challenges etc to be the bridge to the future.

And to that extent I find SRK calling Pakistan a good neighbour and his insistence on picking them as part of his team out of place. They have been far from a “good” neighbour. Since 1947 they have time and again tried to impinge upon our sovereignty, compelled us to a few wars, subjected us to innumerable suicide/terror attacks and tried every trick in the book to disrupt the otherwise harmonious regional situation in our nation. I am nowhere trying to project that India has done its bit with regard to its responsibility towards its diverse population, but that would be a separate discussion.

However, diplomatic dialogue and interaction on multilateral and bilateral platforms should be initiated with Pakistan. We must be aware that having a “failed” state as a neighbour does pose a great threat to India’s quest in becoming a global superpower. I feel that the leaders in Pakistan need to draw lessons for India’s path to progress and try to build institutions that will foster investment, employment, education, health and provide better quality of life to their resident populations. I wish they focus on building their nation to catch up with what India has become rather than try and pull India down into the abyss that they lie in. They must forego the use of military and the ISI coupled with the so called “state and non-state” actors in their aspirations to make India bleed. If they are successful in doing so, they may get closer to being a good and responsible neighbour.


At the same time, I would like India to take a stronger role on multilateral platforms to ensure the development of Pakistan. I don’t have concrete answers but I have some thoughts on how one can progress. We often criticise organizations such as the World Bank and IMF for their policies, but I think India can benefit greatly if these organizations would invest more time and money in countries such as Pakistan, Nepal and Bangladesh. I feel that it is important to engage the youth in Pakistan and other neighbouring countries into activities that will give them sustainable livelihoods and subsequently a better quality of life and present them with alternate means to survival. So for ever Dollar that India would borrow from a donor organization, they must urge them to spend 25 cents or more in Pakistan. It is extremely difficult to convince the private sector to invest in Pakistan and thus the UN/IMF route looks like a feasible option to me. Of course, this support cannot be pure budgetary support, because it defeats the purpose of such investment then owing to the non-existence of institutions, rather the UN/IMF should engage in some sort of nation building activities.

Finally, I would want the members of civil society in Pakistan to become more responsible. They ought to criticize the policies of their government. Only then will I agree that we must not paint the whole of the country with a single brush. I am appalled at the insensitivity of the general population of the land toward the ghastly acts of terror.

I do enjoy a Ghulam Ali and I certainly think that a Wasim Akram, a Jansher Khan or a Suhail Abbas have been magical at their respective professions, but I feel more strongly about an anonymous Jawan who works 18 hours each day patrolling the borders of our country so that you and I live to see a new tomorrow.

No comments: