Wednesday, March 25, 2009

Meow…. Says the dying tiger!!!

It’s my national animal and I am mesmerized by the grandeur of this four legged mammal and thus my views may be biased and overtly emotional. I begin with a word of advice to all those who have not had the opportunity to witness this wonderful animal in its habitat. Spend the next vacation trying to see one in the ever dwindling wilderness because I think you cannot understand what you are missing out on or you may not be fortunate enough if you wait any longer, since there may be none left.

I am looking at the challenge of protecting the tiger and its habitat from two perspectives. The former being economic while the latter using the tools of logic. I am thus tempted to call it an eco-logical approach unless ecologists feel offended with my abuse of language. I did take the effort to trace down the etymology of the word ecology which simply refers to “the study of the relation of plants and animals with their habitat.”

Economics is a science that unreservedly cuts into all aspects of our life and the world we live in and thus I am of the opinion that “saving the tiger” is now more an economic and political issue and should not be left as a problem wanting to be solved by conservationists and the practitioners of ecology alone. If I am to believe the numbers stated in the latest census, India has approximately 1411 tigers left in the wild as compared to 45,000 at the turn of the 19th century. Tiger habitats have shrunk by over 90 percent over the years and now there are more tigers in captivity than in the wild.

I try to isolate reasons that I interpret as critical to the survival and conservation of tiger populations analyse alternate measures to tackle them, where I use economic incentives as a key tool.

I claim that the first step would ensure that the value of a live tiger be greater than or equal to a dead one (here I assume that when indifferent, a tiger is allowed to live).
The value of a dead tiger is easy to estimate, since prices for the various parts of the tiger, skin, bones, claws etc. can be obtained from the markets in which these products are traded.

The bones of one tiger weigh approximately 10 kilograms. The price is estimated at $140-$370 per kilogram in U.S. dollars depending on the size of the bones. In Taiwan, a bowl of tiger penis soup (to boost virility) goes for $320 and a pair of eyes (to fight epilepsy and malaria) for $170. Powdered tiger humerus bone (for treating ulcers rheumatism and typhoid) brings up to $1,450 lb. in Seoul.

To cut a long point short, a dead tiger is worth a lot of money.

The difficult task however is to calculate/estimate the value of a live tiger. I attempt to outline an approach to do the same and leave a detailed rigorous analysis as my PhD thesis topic!!




In the wild a tiger is expected to live between 10 and 15 years. I shall choose to be conservative and peg this number at 10 years. The goal is to make the discounted revenue that a tiger can allow me to earn over a 10 year period greater than the value of a dead tiger.

As a source of revenue I focus on the importance of wildlife tourism and the role of the protector. It’s not difficult to obtain data on the revenues generated by the wildlife sanctuaries in India which should be readily available with the Ministry of Forestry or at the office of the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG). This normally includes park entry fees and revenues generated through government provided lodging facilities. Add to this travel expenditures incurred by an individual, expenditures on hiring vehicles to enter and explore the parks, revenues collected by other lodging and boarding providers around the park. The park authorities also take note of the number of people visiting the parks. Using this data average expenditure per person can be easily estimated.

That will enable to estimate the revenue aspect that can be generated through tourism.

Turning to the management aspect, I must confess that there is enormous scope for improvement. Poachers get tipped about the whereabouts of a tiger from individuals who live within the forests protected area and have substantial knowledge about the local conditions. Many a time these people assist poachers for a reward which if looked at in comparison with the value of the end product would not even work out to 1 percent. Conservation efforts have been aimed at employing locals and providing them with a source of livelihood, which is a step in the positive direction. Normally a forest ranger employed by the government gets a paltry salary that makes it difficult for him to make ends meet. The alternative I suggest her is to make the protector a stakeholder in revenue sharing, and see if desired results follow.

So the revenue sharing rule must be like a proportion based on variables such as the estimated number of tigers in the park, average age of tigers etc.

In essence, make it economically lucrative to keep the tiger alive and make sure the benefits/ profits reach the people who matter.

More analysis will follow!!

No comments: